WoRMS name details

Amphitrite reniformis Bruguiére, 1789

711856  (urn:lsid:marinespecies.org:taxname:711856)

 unaccepted (superseded original combination)
Species
marine
Bruguière, J. G. (1789-1792). <i>Encyclopédie méthodique ou par ordre de matières. Histoire naturelle des vers</i>, volume 1. Paris: Pancoucke. Pp. i-xviii, 1-344 [Livraison 32, June 1789]; 345-757 [Livraison 48, 13 Feb. 1792] [Dates after Evenhuis, 2003, <i>Zootaxa</i>, 166: 37; <i>Zootaxa</i>, 207, some modified by Evenhuis & Petit 2003 Zootaxa 207:1-4]. , available online at https://biodiversitylibrary.org/page/8892006
page(s): 57 [details] 
Neotype  NMW NMW.Z.2001.042.0001, geounit Sandgerdi  
Neotype NMW NMW.Z.2001.042.0001, geounit Sandgerdi [details]
Note Sandgerdi, Iceland, 64.03° -22.7133° (64...  
From editor or global species database
Type locality Sandgerdi, Iceland, 64.03° -22.7133° (64 1.8' N, 22 42.8' W), on shore drifted holdfast [details]
Read, G.; Fauchald, K. (Ed.) (2024). World Polychaeta Database. Amphitrite reniformis Bruguiére, 1789. Accessed through: World Register of Marine Species at: https://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=711856 on 2024-11-21
Date
action
by
2012-12-07 02:51:00Z
created
2018-01-09 04:06:52Z
changed

Creative Commons License The webpage text is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License


original description Bruguière, J. G. (1789-1792). <i>Encyclopédie méthodique ou par ordre de matières. Histoire naturelle des vers</i>, volume 1. Paris: Pancoucke. Pp. i-xviii, 1-344 [Livraison 32, June 1789]; 345-757 [Livraison 48, 13 Feb. 1792] [Dates after Evenhuis, 2003, <i>Zootaxa</i>, 166: 37; <i>Zootaxa</i>, 207, some modified by Evenhuis & Petit 2003 Zootaxa 207:1-4]. , available online at https://biodiversitylibrary.org/page/8892006
page(s): 57 [details] 

additional source Müller, Otto Friedrich. 1771. Von Würmern des süssen und salzigen Wassers. 1-200. H. Mumme and Faber. Copenhagen., available online at https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/page/14389400
page(s): 194, Plate 16, fig 1-3; note: Description of "Die nieren-formige Amphitrite" [kidney-shaped amphitrite] later used by Bruguiére, author of the name A. reniformis [details] 

redescription Knight-Jones, Phyllis; Darbyshire, Teresa; Petersen, Mary E.; Tovar-Hernández, María Ana. (2017). What is <em>Pseudopotamilla </em><em>reniformis </em>(Sabellidae)? Comparisons of populations from Britain, Iceland and Canada with comments on <em>Eudistylia</em> and <em>Schizobranchia</em>. <em>Zootaxa.</em> 4254(2): 201-220., available online at http://www.mapress.com/j/zt/article/view/zootaxa.4254.2.3
page(s): 204; note: Redescription and neotype [details] Available for editors  PDF available [request]

redescription Gmelin, J. F. (1791). Vermes. In: Gmelin J.F. (Ed.) Caroli a Linnaei Systema Naturae per Regna Tria Naturae, Ed. 13. Tome 1(6). G.E. Beer, Lipsiae [Leipzig]. pp. 3021-3910. <em>Systema Naturae. Linneaeus (ed.). Ed. 13.</em> 1: pars. 6., available online at http://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/83098#5
page(s): 3110; note: The usage in the Gmelin 1791 edition of Systema Naturae does not cite Bruguière, 1789, but both cite Müller's informally named Amphitrite with kidney-shaped fan. The usage is only slightly later th...    
The usage in the Gmelin 1791 edition of Systema Naturae does not cite Bruguière, 1789, but both cite Müller's informally named Amphitrite with kidney-shaped fan. The usage is only slightly later than Bruguière, 1789 and it seems likely the Gmelin name usage can be advantageously regarded as Amphitrite reniformis Bruguière, 1789, rather than a new name to be treated as a homonym as both derive from Müller's observation and informal name . Although Johann Friedrich Gmelin was a German, probably not in direct contact with Bruguière
[details] 
Neotype NMW NMW.Z.2001.042.0001, geounit Sandgerdi [details]
From editor or global species database
Authority In brief the author of A reniformis is Bruguiére but the history of the name is complicated. Müller (1771) published a description of "Die nieren-formige Amphitrite" [kidney-shaped Amphitrite], but no binominals were included in the description. Müller's informal name does not enter nomenclature. The content was later used by Bruguiére (1789?: 57) in an encyclopedia organised by genera under the Latin binominal Amphitrite reniformis, and Bruguiére used the abbreviation 'nob.' (nobis = ours) with the name, thus Bruguiére was taken to be originating author of the binominal A. reniformis in several Knight-Jones publications, including Knight-Jones (deceased) et al. (2017). However, in the volume of Bruguière plates (1816? to 1830: 134) Gmelin's usage (p.3110) is credited in the captions. Gmelin is the author of the 13th edition of 'Systema Naturae ...'. of which the first part was published 1788, but the Vermes (vol 1 part 6) was published 1791. Thus Bruguiére was months earlier and remains the author of Amphitrite reniformis. The later mention of Gmelin in the plates atlas is only intended for cross reference, although it is interesting that Gmelin does not mention the usage in Bruguiére. The eventual title page date for Bruguiére's work is actually 1792, but according to Evenhuis & Petit (2003 corrections) the first installment up to page 344 was circulated in 1789 and the 1792 title page is a later replacement. Possibly the two contemporaneous authors Bruguiére and Gmelin used the name independently at the time, each deriving the name from the original entry in Müller, but it seems likely that Gmelin had available to him the 1789 part of Bruguiére. [details]

Editor's comment Some authors have credited Müller with this name, for example Fauvel 1927, but Müller did not use a binominal. The usage in the Gmelin 1791 edition of Systema Naturae does not cite Bruguière, 1789, but both cite Müller's informally named Amphitrite with kidney-shaped fan. Although Johann Friedrich Gmelin was a German, not in direct contact with Bruguière as far as we know, the usage is only slightly later than Bruguière, 1789 and it seems likely the Gmelin name usage can be recorded as Amphitrite reniformis Bruguière, 1789, rather than a new name to be treated as a homonym as both derive secondarily from Müller's observation and informal name rather than arising unrelated by coincidence as most homonyms do .
Users are free to adopt a different treatment of these names if they wish. Lastly McIntosh (1922: 233) credits Leuckart 1849 with the authorship, but doesn't explain why (he is wrong). The first author McIntosh cites is the Gmelin 1791 edition of System Naturae, and he apparently didn't notice the name in Bruguière, 1789. [details]

Neotype Neotype NMW.Z.2001.042.0001 National Museum of Wales, published by Knight-Jones (deceased) et al, 2017 [details]

Type locality Sandgerdi, Iceland, 64.03° -22.7133° (64 1.8' N, 22 42.8' W), on shore drifted holdfast [details]